Last season, Casemiro reportedly grew increasingly dissatisfied with Erik ten Hag’s tactical approach at Manchester United, believing that the Dutch manager’s strategies left him vulnerable on the pitch. The 2023/24 campaign was particularly challenging for United, with the team finishing a disappointing eighth in the Premier League and exiting the Champions League at the group stage. Despite an FA Cup final victory against Manchester City that saved Ten Hag from being sacked, the pressure is once again mounting on the former Ajax boss, especially after a humiliating defeat to Liverpool.
In a recent 3-0 loss at Old Trafford, United’s poor performance, particularly in the first half, drew widespread criticism. Casemiro, a key figure in the team, was subbed off at halftime after a series of mistakes that led to Liverpool’s goals. However, it became evident that not all of the blame rested on the Brazilian midfielder. Liverpool’s third goal, in particular, highlighted flaws in Ten Hag’s tactical setup rather than individual errors.
Arne Slot, Liverpool’s manager, revealed that his strategy was to press high and exploit United’s full-backs being out of position. This approach placed added pressure on Casemiro, who struggled to cope. The match underscored the broader issue of how Ten Hag’s tactics have not only exposed Casemiro but also failed to play to his strengths.
According to Andy Mitten on the Talk of the Devils podcast, Casemiro’s frustration with Ten Hag’s tactics dates back to last season. The 32-year-old felt that the game plans left him exposed and hindered his ability to perform at his best. This tactical misalignment contributed to one of the most challenging seasons of Casemiro’s career, as he found himself struggling at the heart of United’s midfield.
The defeat against Liverpool has raised further questions about whether Casemiro can continue to compete at the highest level under Ten Hag’s system. As United look to regroup after the international break, it wouldn’t be surprising to see Manuel Ugarte, who has been waiting in the wings, step into Casemiro’s role in the starting lineup.
